
Feelings were very mixed about this novel – some people enjoyed it as a superficial read but, if we were looking for a book with more depth, we would perhaps have chosen something else. Gillian Slovo has written many books, but started out as a writer of crime fiction and progressed to novels about more serious issues. This novel is set in Ceylon and England between 1946 and 1972. As well as the class issues relevant in both countries, it addresses the ruptures brought about by colonialism and its aftermath, the problems of race and immigration and how people coped with their experiences.
The novel opens in Ceylon in 1946, and ends in Sri Lanka in 1972, when the country has gained independence. Not only does the country experience great change during these years, but we felt that the characters did too, almost beyond recognition. The two central characters in the story are Evelyn, a beautiful blond English girl, and Emil the handsome, rich son of an upper-class Sinhalese family. Both of them are rebels and, although warned by their families, fall in love and marry. Evelyn was flattered by the attentions of Emil and sees him as a way to get out of an impossible situation. Her family is moving back to England and she has nowhere to go except to be taken in by her sister, whom she doesn’t particularly get on with. Emil’s family disown him after their marriage, but they set up home in Ceylon where they are quite happy until after the birth of their first child Milton, when Evelyn decides that she would like to move to England.
This is really where their problems start, because although Emil has travelled ahead and set up a successful business there using funds lent by his father, Evelyn soon discovers how he is treated by white people. Although very much a rebel in Ceylon, she finds life with Emil in England increasingly difficult to cope with, and her character begins to change. This is perhaps most significant when she prays that her second child will look more like her. We felt that this was the beginning of her own feelings of racism, as it is from this time that she can’t bear Emil to touch her.
Emil on the other hand still has great strength of character, perhaps cushioned by his wealth, not to change throughout the many difficult situations that the author throws at him. We did however feel that some of these were very contrived. Their son, who looks like his father, but who has an awkward relationship with him, is sent away to boarding school by Evelyn. This causes even greater tensions between them, as Milton encounters prejudice and bullying at school. Occasions when his parents visit are full of tension, as Emil refuses to conform and becomes an increasing embarrassment to his wife. Vanessa, their second child, does look more like her mother and is the favourite of her father. Because of her colour she has an easier time, and is able to keep relative peace within the family.
Things come to a head between Evelyn and Emil, when she has an affair with Charles, one of Emil’s junior partners. The marriage ends with Evelyn being thrown out of the family home, and Emil subsequently pretending that she has died. He destroys the Black Orchid of the title, and carries on his life in England. We did feel that Evelyn would never have had an affair with this particular character, but that it was a contrived way for the marriage to end in complete disaster.
Milton is expelled from school, much to the delight of Emil, and comes to work in the family firm. He is now an adolescent brimming with resentment, so their relationship doesn’t get any better. Eventually he finds letters from his mother in Emil’s safe and goes to Ceylon, now Sri Lanka, to track her down. He finds a drunken women whom he simply does not recognise as his mother. She has settled down with a tea plantation owner, and is a shadow of her former self. Ironically, she is shortly going to have to leave the country, under its terms of independence and so we are left with the feeling that their relationship can never be as it was. Milton does, however, feel when he looks at Sri Lanka and its people that for the first time, he finally belongs somewhere.
Although we appreciated these sentiments, we did feel that the ending was very abrupt and didn’t tie up all the loose ends. We wanted to know how this story-line developed and about the characters who had been left behind. Some of the group felt that a sequel to the book was needed, but others that a final chapter could have been added. We did all feel that the book had been readable, but we questioned its depth, and whether the serious issues at its heart were well-presented.
Reviewed by Janine Blomley of Oundle and District U3A book group